The essential job of museums in developing a robust civic identification

Charlotte Higgins is location-on about Derby’s Museum of Generating and the opportunity purpose of museums in civic lifestyle (Go to Derby: see how a museum can support form a improved upcoming, 1 July). Derby Museums has 3 key advantages: a regional authority that understands the worth of tradition and heritage an superb group led by Tony Butler, and an superb assortment – part of which has been formally selected by Arts Council England as currently being of nationwide relevance.

There are 25 civic museum expert services in England with in the same way selected collections, which I am surveying with an Art Fund grant. Jointly, they paint a photo of 19th-century municipal self-assurance and pride supported by industrial wealth and imperial electrical power, ensuing in collections of astonishing richness. Unfortunately, this was adopted by postwar industrial collapse and the erosion of civic powers and funding by central federal government.

These museums and their collections could make a important contribution to local id and the regeneration of our dying city centres, as Derby Museums has carried out, but they want expenditure that displays their countrywide significance.
Dr Ellen McAdam

I have just lately been involved in some exploration on the museum sector, which has an crucial function to participate in in assisting construct a civic tradition in the United kingdom. Even so, when it will come to the operating course, Derby’s Museum of Producing is lacking a large chance. It is not that the museum is not truly worth going to, but like several other individuals it tends to provide a development narrative, in which labour exploitation exists in the distant past, right before moving on to celebrate the technological current. While the museum has lots of intriguing and evocative objects, it has little to say about the complexity of the existence encounters of the functioning course and their struggles in the place of work.

The radical society of the previous proceeds to have a thing to inform us about a environment in which technologies is additional usually utilised to exploit personnel than supply them a dignified lifestyle. I can only hope that the museum sector will request to work with trade unions in the upcoming and supply new methods of connecting the previous and the existing.
Dr Nick Stevenson
Reader in cultural sociology, College of Nottingham

Have an feeling on nearly anything you have study in the Guardian now? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication.