Best Car Insurance Companies in Indianapolis – October 2022

A car is a important property, and you wish to guarantee it’s well-protected in case of an mishap. That’s why car insurance is so crucial, and it’s something you should look into prior to you purchase a policy. There are a lot of various car insurance companies out there, and they all have advantages and disadvantages. To help you narrow down your alternatives, we’ve compiled a list of the best car insurance companies in Indianapolis. We’ve considered elements like customer care, protection options, discount rates, and more to assist you select the best insurance provider for your requirements.

Best Cheap Car Insurance Companies in Indianapolis

Indianapolis is among the most expensive states for car insurance, so shopping around for the very best rates is important. The least expensive car insurance companies in Indianapolis are Geico, State Farm, and Progressive. When searching for car insurance in Indianapolis, compare rates from several companies to discover the very best deal.

Here are the top 5 car insurance companies in Indianapolis:


Geico is Best Car Insurance Companies in Indianapolis

Geico is one of the most widely known and earliest car insurance companies in the United States. The business was founded in 1936 and has ended up being the nation’s second-largest car insurer. Geico offers a large range of insurance items, such as car, house owners, occupants, motorbikes, and boat insurance. The business is well-known for its successful ad campaign including Geico Gecko and other characters.

The Pros and Cons of Geico


  • Available in all 50 states. Geico is an insurance company that provides auto coverage in every state. They provide car insurance to locals no matter where they live in the United States.
  • Easy-to-use. Geico has created a easy to use site and mobile app that is straightforward, simple to utilize, and secure. You can use the platform to manage your insurance policy, file claims, and pay.
  • Plenty of discounts. You can minimize your Geico insurance premiums by taking advantage of the discount rates they provide, such as if you have a clean driving history or are a federal staff member.


  • It only offers through Geico agents. If you’re thinking about working with an independent broker, they won’t be able to price estimate Geico policies. That’s because Geico just sells their policies straight and will not partner with other companies. However, if you ‘d like to compare your choices, we can reveal you prices estimate from top companies without inputting all of your details for each quote.
  • Geico does not finance all of its other items. Geico partners with third-party companies to offer other insurance items, like house owners insurance. That implies that Geico will fulfil your car claim, but you might need to take care of your homeowner’s insurance claim with an agency like AIG.

State Farm

State Farm

State Farm is a large and well-known car insurance company in the United States. The company supplies its clients with a wide variety of protection choices, discounts, and perks. Additionally, State Farm has a strong financial ranking and an extensive network of representatives and claims representatives. State Farm is an exceptional option for reliable and fairly priced auto insurance. With over 80 years of market experience, they have actually supplied quality protection to their consumers at a sensible cost. In addition, they provide numerous discounts and perks that can help you save much more cash.

The Pros and Cons of State Farm


  • History company. The company has a long history of supplying quality coverage and excellent customer support, making it one of the most trusted names in the industry.
  • Coverage choices. State Farm provides comprehensive protection choices so that you can tailor your policy to your particular needs.
  • Rates and discounts. They offer competitive rates and discounts, conserving you cash on your premium.
  • Quick and easy claims procedure. State Farm is understood for its quick and simple claims procedure, which can help you return on the roadway after an accident.


  • Widest range. The business doesn’t have the widest range of coverage options, so you might be not able to find a policy that precisely fits your requirements.
  • Greater rates. State Farm’s rates are normally on the higher side when compared to other insurance providers.
  • Slow processing. Some consumers have grumbled about the claims process, saying it can be sluggish and discouraging.



There are a couple of things to think about when looking for the very best car insurance companies in Indianapolis. The first is price. You’ll want to find a business that uses a reasonable rate on your premium. The second is coverage. You’ll wish to ensure you get the best coverage for your requirements. And the third is customer service. You’ll wish to discover a business with great customer service and simple to work with. Concerning car insurance, progressive companies tend to be more costly than others. But they also use more protection choices, which can be worth the extra expense. Progressive offers numerous types of protection, including crash, thorough, liability, and medical payments. They also have a range of discount rates readily available, consisting of discount rates for excellent drivers, safe chauffeurs, and motorists who have taken a protective driving course.

If you’re looking for the best car insurance companies in Indianapolis, cost isn’t the only thing you must think about. Protection and client service are essential elements as well. But if you’re trying to find a progressive company providing many coverage alternatives and discount rates, then advanced might be the right choice.

The Pros and Cons of Progressive


  • It provides a range of insurance options. So you can find the coverage that Best fits your requirements.
  • One of the largest car insurance companies in the United States. so you can be positive that you’re getting trustworthy protection.
  • Discounts. Offers discount rates for a variety of things, including safe driving, multi-car policies, and more
  • Relied on brand name. It has a well-known and trusted brand, so you can be sure you’re getting quality protection.


  • The company does not have the most extended history in the industry. Founded in 1937, Progressive is one of the more recent insurance providers compared to companies like State Farm and Allstate. Depending upon your perspective, this could be seen as positive or unfavorable.
  • Progressive may not have the most extensive range of coverage choices readily available. While they use basic car insurance coverage, they may not have as many add-on options as other insurance companies.
  • Progressive’s rates are not constantly the least expensive. They are often competitive, however there are often more cost effective options. This is why it’s always crucial to compare rates from numerous insurance providers prior to making a decision.
  • Some clients have complained about client service issues with Progressive. While this is definitely not universal, it is something to be knowledgeable about if you’re considering them as your insurer.


Allstate One of the Best Car Insurance Companies in Indianapolis

Allstate is one of the country’s biggest auto insurance companies, insuring over 16 million vehicles. They offer a wide range of coverage choices and exceptional customer service. Allstate auto insurance is not like your common insurance plan. For starters, Allstate supplies a pay-per-mile program. Driving less can help you conserve money on your insurance premiums. It works by setting up a device in your car that screens your mileage. Then, at the end of monthly, you send out Allstate reports detailing the variety of miles you drove. Allstate will determine your premium for the following month based on this info.

READ MORE  Best Car Insurance Companies in El Monte - December 2022

The Pros and Cons of Allstate


  • Available in all 50 states. Chauffeurs all over the country (including Florida, Alaska and Hawaii) can guarantee their cars and trucks with Allstate, which isn’t real of all of its competitors.
  • High claims satisfaction rankings. Allstate scored 876 out of 1000 on the 2020 J.D. Power Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, putting it above the market average and other major car insurance companies like Geico, Safeco and Liberty Mutual.
  • Vast array of discounts readily available. Allstate provides a long list of discounts for chauffeurs, consisting of cost savings for paying your policy completely, going paperless, and bundling your car with house insurance or another policy through Allstate.
  • Unique savings chances. Allstate also uses its signature Drivewise program. Getting involved motorists use an app that tracks their driving behaviour and can get money off their premiums for safe driving.
  • Will guarantee high-risk chauffeurs. In specific states, Allstate uses non-standard car insurance for motorists considered “high-risk” and may have difficulty finding coverage from other insurance companies.


  • Our sample quote was greater than typical. When we ran a sample quote for an typical motorist through Allstate, we got rates greater than the nationwide average for car insurance. You might require to go into their discount rates to get the best offer on your coverage.
  • Some middling consumer ratings. While Allstate ratings well for claims complete satisfaction, its total consumer ratings are average with third-party firms like J.D. Power and Consumer Reports.



USAA Founded in 1922, USAA is a Fortune 500 company that offers a full series of insurance and monetary services items to more than 13 million members of the military neighborhood and their households.

With its head office in San Antonio, Texas, USAA has more than 30,000 employees and runs in all 50 states. The company’s insurance consists of car, homeowners, life, health, and umbrella coverage.

USAA consistently ranks among the very best car insurance companies regarding customer complete satisfaction. In J.D. Power’s 2020 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, USAA got the highest possible rating in every category, consisting of overall satisfaction, claims satisfaction, policy offerings, rates, and billing process and interactions.

In addition to its exceptional customer care ratings, USAA is likewise among the most affordable car insurance suppliers in Indianapolis. In our study of the best cheap car insurance companies in N.Y., USAA had an typical yearly rate of $1,028– nearly $400 less than the state average!

The Pros and Cons of USAA


  • Competitive rates. One of the most significant benefits of USAA car insurance is its competitive rates. This is essential due to the fact that it can save you a lot of money on your premiums.
  • Exceptional track record. USAA is a widely known and respected business that can give you peace of mind regarding your coverage.
  • Deal numerous discount rates. If you have multiple vehicles or are a safe chauffeur, you might be qualified for discounts on your premium.
  • Have exceptional client service. If you have any questions or issues with your policy, their customer service representatives will be happy to help you.


  • Only operate in particular states. This implies that if you transfer to a different state, you will no longer have the ability to keep your policy with them.
  • Not cover all of the damages brought on by accident. This implies that if your car is totalled, you might not get adequate cash from

How Much Does Car Insurance Cost in Indianapolis?

Indianapolis car insurance rates are some of the highest in the country, but there are still ways to conserve. Let’s look at the typical expense of car insurance in Indianapolis and a few of the best ways to get less expensive protection.

How Much Does Average Car Insurance Cost in Indianapolis?

The typical cost of car insurance in Indianapolis is almost $400 above the national average. The high cost of car insurance in Indianapolis is generally due to the high number of accidents and thefts in the state.

Numerous factors impact the cost of car insurance in Indianapolis. These include the type of vehicle you drive, your driving record, your age, where you live, and the amount of protection you need.

If you’re searching for ways to save on car insurance in Indianapolis, consider raising your deductible, making the most of discounts, and looking around for the best rates.

How to Find the very best Car Insurance in Indianapolis?

If you’re looking for the very best car insurance in Indianapolis, there are a few things you’ll wish to keep in mind. First, consider your requirements and budget plan. What kind of coverage do you need? How Much can you afford to spend? When you have a good concept of what you’re searching for, start comparing rates from different insurance companies.

A couple of excellent resources can assist you compare rates and find the very best deal. The Indianapolis State Insurance Department’s website lists insurance companies and their contact details. You can also utilize an online quote comparison tool like The Zebra to get quotes from multiple insurance companies.

When you’re prepared to buy, shop around and compare rates prior to choosing a policy. Likewise, guarantee you understand your policy’s terms and conditions before signing on the dotted line.

Car Insurance Discounts in Indianapolis

There are several discount rates offered to Indianapolis drivers concerning car insurance. Numerous insurers use a discount for taking motorist’s education courses, and there are also discount rates offered for young chauffeurs who preserve excellent grades in school. In addition, some insurers provide a “pay-as-you-drive” discount based upon the amount of driving you do each year.

You might be eligible for numerous discount rates if you have a tidy driving record, including a safe chauffeur discount or a good student discount rate. Some insurance companies likewise use discounts for installing particular safety gadgets in your cars, such as anti-theft or mishap avoidance systems. Finally, many insurers offer commitment discounts for clients who have been with the business for a certain period.

Often Asked Questions

What Are the Different Types of Car Insurance Coverage Offered in Indianapolis?

There are many different kinds of best car insurance protection readily available in Indianapolis. The most common types are accident, comprehensive, liability, and personal injury security (PIP). Accident protection pays for damage to your vehicle if you hit another item. On the other hand, comprehensive coverage pays for damage to your car from occasions such as fire, theft, or vandalism. Liability protection protects you if you are responsible for damages or injuries caused to another person. At the same time, PIP spends for medical expenditures and lost incomes if you are hurt in a car accident.

READ MORE  Best Car Insurance Companies in Atlanta - December 2022

What Are the Minimum Liability Requirements for Car Insurance in Indianapolis?

The minimum liability requirements for car insurance in Indianapolis are $25,000/$50,000/$10,000. Your insurance provider will pay up to $25,000 for injuries sustained by someone in an accident, $50,000 for injuries sustained by 2 or more people in an mishap, and $10,000 for home damage triggered by accident. However, it is necessary to keep in mind that these are only the minimum requirements, and you may need higher limitations depending on your scenario.

How Can I Get the very best Deal on Car Insurance in Indianapolis?

You can do a couple of things to get the best deal on car insurance in Indianapolis. One is to search and compare rates from different companies. Another is to take advantage of discount rates that might be readily available, such as a great motorist discount rate or a discount rate for having several policies with the same company. You can likewise raise your deductible to reduce your premium.

What Other Factors Should I Consider When Shopping for Car Insurance in Indianapolis?

When searching for the best car insurance companies in Indianapolis, you must consider other elements, such as your vehicle type, driving history, and circumstances. For instance, if you reside in an location with a high crime rate, you may wish to purchase thorough protection to safeguard your vehicle from theft or vandalism. If you have a bad driving history, you may want to buy greater limitations of liability coverage.

What is the Best Car Insurance in Indianapolis?

When it pertains to car insurance, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. The best car insurance for you will depend upon a number of elements, including your driving record, the worth of your car, and your budget.

That stated, some insurance companies are cheaper than others in Indianapolis. Based on our research, the 3 most budget-friendly car insurance companies in Indianapolis are Geico, Progressive, and State Farm.

Geico is the largest auto insurance provider in the United States and offers a variety of discounts, consisting of for good chauffeurs and members of particular professional companies.

Progressive is another big insurance company with a wide range of discount rates for safe motorists and those who sign up for automated payments.

State Farm is the biggest provider of house owners’ insurance in the United States and likewise provides car insurance. It offers a range of discount rates, including for safe motorists and great trainees.

Is Car Insurance Required in Indianapolis?

Yes, car insurance is needed in Indianapolis. All chauffeurs in Indianapolis should have liability insurance, which covers damages to other people and home in the event of an mishap. You need to also have uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, which secures you if you’re hit by a driver who does not have insurance or does not have enough insurance to cover your damages.

How Much Car Insurance Do I Need in Indianapolis?

Indianapolis law needs all motorists to have car insurance. The minimum protection you must purchase is $25,000 for physical injury liability per individual, $50,000 for physical injury liability per accident, and $10,000 for residential or commercial property damage liability per accident. Nevertheless, these are just the minimum amounts required by law. You may want to acquire more than the minimum limits to secure yourself financially.

Can Bad Credit Affect the Cost of My Car Insurance?

Numerous believe their credit score will not affect their car insurance rates, however this is not always the case. In Indianapolis, insurance companies can use your credit details when calculating your premium. This practice is called “credit-based insurance scoring” and can significantly impact your car insurance expense.

If you have a poor credit score, you might be seen as a high-risk motorist and be needed to pay a higher premium. On the other hand, if you have a good credit report, you might be qualified for discount rates and may wind up paying less for your car insurance.

All insurance providers do not utilize credit-based insurance scoring in Indianapolis, so it’s necessary to search and compare rates from several companies before selecting a policy. Be sure to ask each insurance provider if they use credit information when setting rates and how it could impact your premium.

Why is Car Insurance Expensive in Indianapolis?

Indianapolis car insurance rates are expensive since of the high expense of living in the state. Indianapolis need to pay more for gas, repairs, and other car-related expenses than people in other states. The Indianapolis invests about $2,200 a year on car insurance, nearly double the national average.

There are a couple of reasons car insurance is so expensive in Indianapolis. One reason is that the state has a lot of densely inhabited locations. This suggests that there are more automobiles on the road and more opportunities for mishaps to take place. Indianapolis also has lots of tourist destinations, indicating out-of-state chauffeurs are most likely to enter mishaps.

Another factor car insurance is pricey in Indianapolis is that the state needs all chauffeurs to bring personal injury protection (PIP) coverage. PIP spends for medical costs and lost wages if you’re injured in an mishap. It’s required in many states, however Indianapolis’s PIP protection is amongst the most comprehensive and pricey in the country.

If you reside in Indianapolis or are considering moving there, comparing car insurance rates from various companies before buying a policy is vital. The rates can differ substantially from business to business, so it pays to shop around. You can utilize our tool below to compare rates from various companies and discover the very best deal for your scenario.

Why Do Car Insurance Rates Vary by Company and Driver?

There are many aspects that insurance companies consider when setting rates, consisting of the motorist’s age, gender, driving history, and the kind of car being insured. However, the most vital aspects are company-specific underwriting criteria and claims experience.

Underwriting is the insurance provider’s procedure to decide whether to accept or decline a prospective consumer. Each company has different underwriting standards, so some might be more going to insure high-risk drivers than others. Claims experience is another crucial factor that can trigger rates to differ from company to company. If an insurance provider has actually had a lot of claims filed versus it in a particular state or for a particular type of vehicle, it might charge higher rates to offset its losses.

The best method to determine which company has the very best rates for you is to shop around and compare quotes from numerous insurance providers. Make certain you’re comparing apples to apples by getting quotes for the very same level of protection from each business. And don’t forget to ask about any discounts that might be offered.

READ MORE  Best Car Insurance Companies in Fontana - December 2022

Image Source:,,,,